毫无疑问的是,The Accused一直都被认为是一部关于司法审判的佳作,由司法入手再谈暴力行为和社会问题,是比较正统的路数。
不过今天想到是从另外两个不同的角度来谈谈由这部电影可以引发的关于社会问题的思考。
其一,就是在这部电影中呈现而出,但是被很多人所忽略的女权主义批评,从女权的角度看,主人公莎拉的遭遇几乎和Boys Don't Cry中的希拉里·斯旺克扮演的角色殊途同归,当莎拉如男人一般“粗鲁”地生活,借口“星相学”而不是依靠男人来决定自己的行为举止等等(20年后,当年看起来如此特立独行的方式也流于烂俗了),这个人物已经可以被标识为具有“女性主义觉醒意识”了,但是当莎拉在酒吧中的种种举止,被中立观点可以认为是类似于男性“富有攻击性”时,却被当时在酒吧里的所有男人认为是“富有攻击‘性’”而已,事后在法庭上,几乎所有的男性证人都认为强暴案的发生归因于莎拉的“举止不端”,由此可见,这部电影中关于女性主义的一个观点就是,如果女性想通过模仿或者类比于男性的方式来表现自己的抗争,那么结果只会是更加不幸的
不得不承认,作为一个在中国大陆出生、长大的普通女性,在日常生活中,当说到“强奸”这个词的时候,我都会有意无意地替换为另一个词“强暴”——正如这部电影中,控告三名强奸犯时,被告律师提议将“强奸罪”替换为“故意伤害罪”——似乎“暴力”比“性暴力”更容易被接受一些;似乎这样,受害者的难堪处境就能够得到缓解。
而且,有这样想法的人不仅止我一个,我周围的大多数女性,在公共场合谈论“强奸”这样的话题,好像令她们感觉自己的尊严受到了侮辱,自己的学识和智慧甚至也被这个可怕的词抵消了。
因为说到茱迪•福斯特,想起来这个片子。每次看都让我的心(愤怒地)颤抖不已。茱迪•福斯特的表演无愧于当年的小金人。
生活中时时刻刻作为一个旁观者,每个人都是罪人。
P.S:看这种片子的副作用就是起码在一小时内脑海中只有两句话:
男人都他妈是猪!!!
某些女人真他妈是弱者!!!
「Ladies and Gentleman, Mr. Paulson has told you the testimony of Sarah Tobias is nothing. Sarah Tobias was raped but that is nothing. She was cut, and bruised, and terrorized, but that is nothing. All of it happened in front of a howling crowd and that is nothing. Well, it may be nothing to Mr. Paulson, but it is not nothing to Sarah Tobias and I don't believe it's nothing to you. Next, Mr. Paulson tried to convince you that Kenneth Joyce was the only person in that room who knew that Sarah Tobias was being raped. The only one. Now you watched Kenneth Joyce, how did he strike you? Did he seem especially sensitive? Especially observant? Did he seem so remarkable that you immediately said to yourselves, "Of course. This man would notice things other people wouldn't." Do you believe that Kenneth Joyce saw something those three man didn't see? In all the time that Sarah Tobias was held d
神剧必备!《被告》(暴劫梨花):隔靴搔痒之作!―― 完美世界更需要同理心,而非同情心
转载请注明网址: https://www.2007dy.com/vod/id-19910.html